Compare car insurance quotes
Pick two or more companies to see rates where you live. Free, no obligation.
What makes a driver high risk
Insurers sort drivers into standard and nonstandard (high-risk) groups. You may be placed in the nonstandard market if you have:
- A DUI or DWI conviction, or a reckless-driving conviction
- Several at-fault accidents or moving violations in a few years
- A lapse in insurance coverage
- A suspended or revoked license, or a requirement to file an SR-22
- Little or no U.S. driving history, including newly licensed and young drivers
- Poor credit, in states where insurers may use it
Nonstandard insurance uses the same coverage types as a normal policy: liability, collision, comprehensive and so on. The difference is cost, a smaller choice of insurers, and sometimes stricter payment terms.
How much violations raise your premium
| Violation | Average full coverage / yr | Increase |
|---|---|---|
| Clean record | $2,578 | – |
| One speeding ticket | $3,568 | +38% |
| One at-fault accident | $4,129 | +60% |
| Two speeding tickets | $4,196 | +63% |
| First DUI | $4,959 | +92% |
| Poor credit | $5,478 | +113% |
| Second DUI | $8,307 | +222% |
Source: CarInsurance.com, August 2026; 40-year-old driver, 100/300/100 liability, $500 deductibles.
Where to find cover
Many large insurers will still quote high-risk drivers. In CarInsurance.com’s September 2026 data, Travelers had the lowest average full-coverage prices after an at-fault accident ($2,823), a speeding ticket ($2,801) and a DUI ($2,933), and GEICO was cheapest for drivers with poor credit ($3,555). GEICO and Progressive also write nonstandard business.
Specialist nonstandard insurers include Dairyland, The General, Direct Auto, Kemper, Founders and Safe Auto. They may accept drivers that standard companies decline, but compare their prices carefully: they aren’t automatically cheaper.
If no company will insure you, every state has a residual market (often called an assigned-risk plan) that guarantees access to at least minimum liability cover. It’s usually the most expensive option and a last resort.
SR-22 and FR-44 filings
An SR-22 isn’t insurance. It’s a certificate your insurer files with the state to prove you carry at least the minimum required liability cover. Courts or DMVs usually require one after a DUI, driving uninsured, serious violations or a license suspension, typically for about three years. If your policy lapses, the insurer must notify the state, which can suspend your license again.
Florida and Virginia use an FR-44 for DUI cases, which requires higher liability limits than a normal SR-22. For costs, state rules and options if you don’t own a car, see our SR-22 insurance guide and SR-22 costs.
How to get back to standard rates
- Keep continuous coverage. A lapse makes everything harder and more expensive.
- Drive clean. Speeding tickets typically affect your price for about three years; accidents three to five; DUIs often longer.
- Take a defensive driving course where your state or insurer gives credit for it.
- Raise your deductible and consider liability-only cover on an older car to keep the premium manageable; see full coverage vs. liability.
- Re-shop every renewal. When a violation ages off your record, insurers that declined you before may now offer standard rates.
- Try telematics once you’re eligible. A good driving score can offset some of the surcharge; see usage-based insurance.
What a DUI costs over three years
Using CarInsurance.com’s 2026 averages, a first DUI raises full-coverage premiums from $2,578 to $4,959 a year, an extra $2,381. If the surcharge lasts three years, that’s about $7,100 in extra premiums alone, before fines, legal fees, SR-22 filing fees or license reinstatement costs. A second DUI raises the average to $8,307 a year, more than three times the clean-record price.
The spread between insurers makes shopping essential. Travelers’ average DUI price of $2,933 was about $2,000 a year below the industry average, which over three years is worth more than most drivers’ deductibles.
Be honest on applications
Insurers check motor vehicle records and claims databases. Leaving a violation off an application doesn’t hide it, and misrepresentation can lead to a denied claim or a cancelled policy. That cancellation then makes the next policy harder to get. It’s always better to disclose and compare honest quotes.
Frequently asked questions
How long does a DUI affect car insurance?
Usually at least three to five years, and in some states longer. Insurers look back over a set period, and SR-22 or FR-44 filing requirements typically last about three years.
Who has the cheapest insurance after a DUI?
In 2026 national averages, Travelers was cheapest at about $2,933 a year for full coverage, compared with an industry average of $4,959. Local prices vary, so compare several insurers.
Can an insurer refuse to cover me?
Yes. Private insurers can decline applicants they consider too risky. Every state has a residual market plan that guarantees access to minimum liability cover.
Is nonstandard insurance worse coverage?
The coverages are the same types, but prices are higher and payment terms can be stricter. Read the policy and check the insurer’s complaint record before buying.
Does a coverage lapse make me high risk?
It can. Even a short gap often leads to higher quotes, so arrange a new policy before cancelling the old one.
Sources
- CarInsurance.com – How much is car insurance? (Aug 2026)
- CarInsurance.com – Cheapest car insurance (Sept 2026)
- CarInsurance.com – Standard vs. nonstandard car insurance
- GEICO – SR-22 details
- Experian – States that restrict credit-based insurance scores
- CarInsurance.com – Auto insurers ranked by NAIC complaint data (Aug 2026)
- Insurify – Progressive Snapshot review
Insurance prices, discounts and rules change often and vary by state. Figures were checked in October 2026; confirm details with the insurer or your state insurance department.